Colts Reportedly Offered FA QB Daniel Jones “Super Bowl LX Champion Sam Darnold Money,” but His Camp Responded With Lofty Counteroffer

Indianapolis, Indiana — Contract negotiations between the Indianapolis Colts and quarterback Daniel Jones have quickly become one of the most talked-about storylines of the early 2026 NFL offseason. According to multiple league sources, Indianapolis made a serious effort to keep its starting quarterback by offering a deal comparable to the contract Super Bowl LX champion Sam Darnold received last offseason.

That agreement was worth three years and approximately $100.5 million, including more than $55 million guaranteed, a figure that would have placed Jones among the better-paid quarterbacks in the league while still giving the Colts flexibility with their salary cap moving forward. However, negotiations reportedly stalled quickly after Jones’ representatives returned with a significantly larger counteroffer.

Sources around the NFL say Jones’ camp sought a contract worth roughly $50 million per year, a salary level typically reserved for the elite quarterbacks at the top of the league. The request reportedly surprised the Colts’ front office and immediately created a significant gap between the two sides during negotiations.

Rather than move forward with a franchise tag, Indianapolis ultimately decided to apply the transition tag worth approximately $37.8 million for the 2026 season, allowing the team to retain negotiating rights while still giving Jones the ability to explore the market.

The situation is further complicated by Jones’ recent injury history. The quarterback was in the middle of what many considered a breakout campaign during his first season with the Colts before suffering a torn Achilles late in the year. Prior to the injury, Jones had delivered an impressive season, throwing for more than 3,900 yards with 29 touchdowns and just eight interceptions, while adding nearly 500 rushing yards and helping keep Indianapolis firmly in the playoff race for much of the season.

Throughout his NFL career, Jones has also produced several memorable moments, including a 2022 playoff victory in the Wild Card round, where he became one of the few quarterbacks in league history to record 300+ passing yards and 70+ rushing yards in a single postseason game.

“Daniel showed us exactly why this team believed in him,” a league source familiar with the Colts’ thinking said.
“But negotiations at the quarterback position can change very quickly once numbers like fifty million dollars per year enter the conversation.”

From Jones’ perspective, the counteroffer reflects the leverage he could gain if he performs at a high level again in 2026. A strong season could dramatically increase his value on the open market.

For Indianapolis, however, the objective remains clear: structure a deal that maintains long-term stability at quarterback without committing to a contract that could severely limit roster flexibility.

The Colts also continue building their offense around key playmakers such as Jonathan Taylor, Michael Pittman Jr., and rising receiver Josh Downs — a core the organization believes can compete deep into the playoffs with the right leadership under center.

Whether that leadership continues to come from Daniel Jones remains one of the biggest questions of the offseason. For now, negotiations remain open, and both sides understand that a compromise may ultimately represent the best path forward.